Would you like me to review a fanfic of yours in an in-depth way?
Post here, and I'll give you your share of "Tysyacha's Thousand
Words." I'll write a thousand-word review or so, and it'll be
clear and in-depth. I have some ground rules, though. ;)
1. I can't write 1000 words about a progressing fanfic (not
a "shortie fic") that only has one or two paragraphs in it,
and one post. Sorry!
2. I would love to do "shortie fics" as well as longer ones.
3. If I do review you and say something negative, I NEVER
mean to hurt your feelings. I just want your story to be 110%! ;)
Sincerely,
Tysyacha
Cool, could you review [FIC]Amongst the Ruins (
http://www.lucasforums.com/showthread.php?t=164927)?) It's a progressing fanfic, so you don't have to write 1000 words. :)
Though, isn't this kind of taking away from Mach's job? That doesn't mean you can't review my fic, I suppose. Please do, and thanks. :)
Though, isn't this kind of taking away from Mach's job? That doesn't mean you can't review my fic, I suppose. Please do, and thanks. :)
I have to agree. Why do I get the feeling that this will get closed? Anyway if you have time, please could you review either of my two Fics (In my Sig)?
Also the Title of this Thread sounds like a Fortune Teller.
Edit: Thanks for reccomending Darkness Rising in your Sig, Ztalker.
oh, please check my Mace Windu: Jedi Master Reborn fic. link is in the sig.
I would appreciate it if you would check out Misplaced Trust (
http://www.lucasforums.com/showthread.php?t=168344), Ease of Darkness (
http://www.lucasforums.com/showthread.php?t=168354), Historical Revelation (
http://www.lucasforums.com/showthread.php?p=2140800), and Shattered Love, Shattered Faith (
http://www.lucasforums.com/showthread.php?t=168424) at some point. They're all short fics. Even if you just posted a small review in the threads themselves. Nobody seems to be viewing them at all, really...
Sorry Tysy but I have to lock this thread.
Mach has a special sticky thread as he's the "official" reviewer at starwarsknights.com. Unfortunately, we cannot allow everyone to start their own general review thread as the forums would become somewhat messy: we would have the fanfic threads free of comments on one side sinking down at the bottom of the forums and general review threads on the other side.
Understand that I don't want to discourage you from posting reviews of other people's fanfics. On the contrary, you are more than welcome to do so but as The Doctor pointed out, you can post them in the fanfic threads themselves: that's what they're for :)
I imagine that if people post their fics in the CEC forum it's because they want them to be viewed and seek some feedback. In fact, I don't know any author/modder/artist who doesn't like to get feedback on his own work so feel free to comment on any fanfic you want. I'm sure everyone will be happy to get your feedback :)