Note: LucasForums Archive Project
The content here was reconstructed by scraping the Wayback Machine in an effort to restore some of what was lost when LF went down. The LucasForums Archive Project claims no ownership over the content or assets that were archived on archive.org.

This project is meant for research purposes only.

Router Help (Xbox Live)

Page: 1 of 1
 Commander Obi-Wan
08-24-2007, 2:09 PM
#1
This section seems the most appropriate area to ask such a question.

It's more of an opinion I need, rather than asking a question. For those who have an Xbox 360 (I assume that Astro may not be able to help with this one ;)), I am wondering, which router(s) are efficient and effective when trying to connect to Xbox Live?

At the moment, I am looking into which one I should get. Since I have minimal knowledge regarding this type of technology. :confused:

I have been doing some research. I am particularly in interested in a router (I only have a modem, in which I can only connect the internet to my PC) that is wireless (and can be connected through an Ethernet cable as well). Though, wireless will do since I am playing from room and my computer is a good 15 or so feet a way from my computer in a separate room.

I would just like opinions from other members about what routers work the best for you. :)
 stingerhs
08-25-2007, 3:45 AM
#2
when it comes to wireless, i swear by Netgear and D-Link for anything and everything. Linksys used to be a good option, but its been my experience that they don't tend to be very reliable after a while. also, make sure you steer clear of Wireless-N devices. wireless-N still isn't standardized, and since the 360 wireless adapter is an 802.11g device, its not going to support the higher speeds anyway.

with the 360, connecting to a wireless router is similar to connecting a PC wirelessly to a router. all you need to know is the SSID and the pass code (if you need one). the 360 supports WEP and WPA encryption; so you can still run a relatively secure wireless network while you're at it.

the biggest problem you might have is with the router's built-in firewall as it might be blocking the TCP or UDP ports that Xbox Live utilizes (whichever ones it uses, i have no idea). if you do end up having problems, that would be the first thing you should check. otherwise, i can't foresee you having any problems as long as you get a good router.

good luck making up your mind. :)
 Astrotoy7
08-25-2007, 9:14 AM
#3
when it comes to wireless, i swear by Netgear and D-Link for anything and everything. Linksys .....

Linkysys formally no longer exists... :) They are Cisco now - though I imagine their products are still supported.

I have many friends that are xbox gamers, and they swear by this gadget...
http://media.teamxbox.com/dailyposts/hardware/DGL-4300/gamerlounge.jpg)

here's a review (http://hardware.teamxbox.com/articles/xbox/1044/DLink-Wireless-108G-Gaming-Router-Review/p1/)

some "real people" reviews at newegg (http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16833127158) are always a handy read.

good luck :D

mtfbwya
 Commander Obi-Wan
08-25-2007, 12:46 PM
#4
Thanks for the help, stingerhs and Astrotoy7 for the advice and your suggestions. :)

More people are welcome to input since I still want to be quite sure on the router I plan to purchase.
 Char Ell
08-25-2007, 2:29 PM
#5
Linksys used to be a good option, but its been my experience that they don't tend to be very reliable after a while. This has been my experience as well. I've gone through 2 Linksys routers in 4 years and am currently looking for a non-Linksys wireless and wired router. :D
Linkysys formally no longer exists... They are Cisco now - though I imagine their products are still supported. True that Cisco purchased Linksys a few years back but Cisco still produces and sells SOHO networking products using the Linksys brand in direct competition with DLink and Netgear. http://www.linksys.com)
Maybe Linksys doesn't operate in The Land Down Under anymore?
 Astrotoy7
08-26-2007, 9:47 AM
#6
Initially, the linksys brand was reported to be on a phase out plan (reported late July 2007), which is when I heard of it last. Cisco have since put a stop on it, for the time being...

READ (http://www.gizmodo.com/gadgets/cisco/)

so rejoice all you linksys fans :D

Im a belkin fan myself. Never had one iota of a problem with their kit. Never used d-link because their stuff is ugly! (except that pictured above perhaps)

...netgear is a swear word for me... long, long, long story, involving $hit hardware and $hit support from Calcuttas finest :( but i wont rant ;)

mtfbwya
Page: 1 of 1