Ok, here we go, the new question people:
Would you rather have the old voices from the first game rehired to do the new game
Would you rather have the guys who did the cartoon come back to do the voices
Or, would you rather have someone completely new?
I don't think any of the 4 voices have done them justice. Sam in hit the road got the detective thing down, but Sam's a pretty emotional guy and that wasn't there at all. The cartoon Sam got Sam's sappy/emotional side better but he sort of sounded like a goofy old man. Basically same goes for max. Game: sounds more like I'd imagine him talking, but too dry. Cartoon: closer, except he's way extra wacky. Both of these problems could depend on the voice director, too, though.
Keep the old guys!!!
Just as long as they don't changes Max's voice. Mind you, Sam's I want to keep too, but Max has the perfect voice in Hit the Road that fits his character.
And Sam's voice fits him a little, and he definitely sounds the detective type. So then instead of voting Keep Max and new Sam, I chose too keep them both. I hope the new game will be better, harder, bigger, and of course, funnier!
maxs voice in the game was perfect