Note: LucasForums Archive Project
The content here was reconstructed by scraping the Wayback Machine in an effort to restore some of what was lost when LF went down. The LucasForums Archive Project claims no ownership over the content or assets that were archived on archive.org.

This project is meant for research purposes only.

Trek VS. Wars

Page: 2 of 3
 Hannibal
07-10-2001, 12:35 PM
#51
Originally posted by Kirvan_Vax:
<STRONG>(does anyone remember Rho? The guy who got banned for porn?)

[ July 09, 2001: Message edited by: Kirvan_Vax ]</STRONG>

Hehehe. I remember that! That was cruel what he did. He posted pics for people's signature on his website then changed the pics to nasty pictures(oops :)) but kept the same address.

[ July 10, 2001: Message edited by: Hannibal ]
 obi
07-10-2001, 12:38 PM
#52
yea, rho thought he could get away with it.

HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA HA!

BTW,hannabal, your signature is funny :D
 Uutont Fжr Uulion
07-10-2001, 4:35 PM
#53
Originally posted by obi-wan13:
<STRONG>you CAN be more than 1 person here.</STRONG>

I am four people
Uutont Fжr Uulion
my normal character
Darth Cindy
for when I want you just can't say something and have it come out right if your not a girl ex: girl1: does this dress make me look fat. Darth Cindy: oh stuff a sock in it.
Yoda the Hutt
Likes big guns and is kind of an outcast.
bob the relentless
same as Yoda the Hutt, but is still trying to get kicked out.


:p :) :rolleyes: :mad: :eek: ;) :cool:
 Boba Rhett
07-10-2001, 4:41 PM
#54
But why? WHY?!
 Hannibal
07-10-2001, 7:10 PM
#55
Yeah, Why?!
 obi
07-11-2001, 11:26 AM
#56
i've already explained my situation.
 Uutont Fжr Uulion
07-11-2001, 9:00 PM
#57
I originally only had one
Uutont Fжr Uulion
then I got my friends on here
Bowdie and Cindy
bob the relentless
and
Darth Cindy
then bowdie forgot his password and didn't know what to do so he started
Yoda the Hutt
then after a week they all left and told me their passwords.
so everyonce in a while I will post under one of those names
:)
any more questions?
 Darth Cindy
07-11-2001, 9:05 PM
#58
But still why
I don't understand
 bob the relentless
07-11-2001, 9:09 PM
#59
oh stuff a sock in it :rolleyes:
 oninosensi
07-12-2001, 12:27 PM
#60
Why would you want to be more than one person? Trying to express what all the voices in your head are saying?
 BeastMaster
07-12-2001, 2:18 PM
#61
For the same reason that (some) people write SF; sometimes it's impossible to comment on something from a certain perspective.

Swinging us back on-thread, that's the purpose of the aliens in Star Trek. They're not intended to be realistic civilizations, they're meant to be twisted reflections of some part of human nature.

Star Trek is an allegory, Star Wars is an adventure story with philosophical subtexts.

Apples and oranges.

BTW, I have two different personas here, and three over on XWA.net (the same two, plus one more. I generally only use the alternates for comedic emphasis (i.e., when a joke would be funnier from them then from me).
 Borg Collective
07-12-2001, 2:28 PM
#62
Originally posted by Kirvan_Vax:
<STRONG>NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO you can't be 2 people at once on a board!!!!!!!!!!!</STRONG>

Why not?

We are several billion individuals at once.
 Jean-Luc_Picard
07-13-2001, 1:24 AM
#63
uh -oh, RED ALERT!!!!!!!!!

all hands to battle stations!!!!!!!

DATA: We have several borg cubes closing in,sir.

Picard: On screen.(Beeing once assimilated in the collective, Picard hears the chant of the borg. "come to us Locutes" they say.
Lock Phasers!

Engage! fire!

.............sorry, had a little flashback there.
:D :D :D
 Darth Prime
07-15-2001, 2:04 AM
#64
How's about I flashack you? in case anyone hasn't noticed, I'm both mad and kinda upset right now. Someone who graduated with my brother a little over a month ago died last week in an accident.
 Boba Rhett
07-15-2001, 4:50 AM
#65
You have to realize that maybe your not the only one that's having problems. Perhaps the reason people here goof off is because it helps them relax and eases their tensions. "An escape from the reality", if you will.

Everyone deals with problems in different ways and we all have to learn to respect that. So from now on, i'll try not to goof off in your threads and hopefully you wont mind it when some of use goof off in other threads. :)
 obi
07-15-2001, 11:42 AM
#66
nicely said rhett.

and this is a topic I started, and i said i don't care if people goof off. im one of those people who just relax in life.

and i agree with everything rhett said, cause in real life, its harsh, people get sick, people die, people starve,abortion,love-loss,pain,suffering.

here, its all good.

i have done anything to hurt your feelins, so that little "how bout i flashback you?" remark was not neccesary.
 Darth Prime
07-16-2001, 2:29 AM
#67
sorry for the way I've been. but, I get real edgy most of the time. and about these goofy whatever-they're-called, I get some of them, but I just think they're weird, and, with all honesty, kinda stupid. All I ask is that you guys and gals don't say anything goofy when I start the topic, one for which I want a serious answer, if I ask question. And in return, I'll stop saying things that are unnecessary.
 BeastMaster
07-16-2001, 1:43 PM
#68
Duly noted, Prime = serious.

And condolences for your loss.
 Darth Prime
07-18-2001, 1:08 AM
#69
BeastMaster, what loss? I seriously have no clue on what you are talking about. And, no, I'm not joking in case anybody thinks I am. I don't understand it myself, but I forget things and have no clue on what anybody is talking about....and how in the world did I get off the topic?
 MadPoster
07-18-2001, 1:53 PM
#70
There is a topic here?
 Pootie
07-18-2001, 3:32 PM
#71
You immature little kids!!

Especially you, Rhett Peterson! ;)
 Borg Collective
07-18-2001, 4:23 PM
#72
Did we cause problems again?
 Kurgan
07-18-2001, 8:08 PM
#73
Darth Prime:

I'm both mad and kinda upset right now. Someone who graduated with my brother a little over a month ago died last week in an accident.


My condolensces on your loss.
 shackie-trekkie
07-18-2001, 8:46 PM
#74
Hey wait a minute- Darth Prime. I thought it was the Prime Directive. Freaken Star Wars episode. What about Star Trek. I mean the Federation no one can top that. Shoot the Death star come one even one of the older class federation ships can take it out with one photon torpedo!! :mad: :confused:
 obi
07-18-2001, 9:02 PM
#75
you needn't waist a photon torpedo, just give it a few licks with a phaser from Enterprise E
 Uutont Fжr Uulion
07-18-2001, 9:12 PM
#76
since we seem to be almost back on topic again

anybody want a cookie :)
 Hannibal
07-18-2001, 9:18 PM
#77
Sure I'll have one. :)

BTW I smell terrific!!!
 Darth Prime
07-19-2001, 1:18 AM
#78
shakie-trekkie, do you honestly think an older starship has a chance against a battle station that's 120 kilometers in diameter. my brother went to a website where the Star Trek and Star Wars universes cross paths, and even a Galaxy-class starship (obivously being the Enterprise-D) couldn't destroy the TIE fighters. So, all the Death Star would have to do is launch it's TIE squadrons, and they'll more than likely be able to take it out.
 Darth Prime
07-19-2001, 1:32 AM
#79
shackie-trekkie, TIE's can take out a starship from Star Trek. Of course, there'll have to be a large number of them. The reason I say that is because with the TIE's as small and manuverable, with the exception of the TIE Bomber, and, as you all know, they make up for their having no shields and sheer numbers. My brother read something on a website, I can't remember what it is, anyway, these TIE's were attacking the Enterprise-D, and even that had trouble locking on to them. If TIE's can cause damage to a starship, then surely the Death Star can destroy one....maybe more, I wouldn't know.
 obi
07-19-2001, 10:12 AM
#80
tie fighters small and monuverable,eh?

all the enterprise has to do is send in the valkerys.
 BeastMaster
07-19-2001, 3:54 PM
#81
I see someone else familiar with Star Trek: Invasion. :cool:

Which Valkyries were you talking about, the type Is, IIs, or IIIs?

Personally, I like the Type I ship. Valkyrie mark II looks like it was built by klingons, and the mark III just looks bizarre.

Here's one for ya: The Defiant (commanded by Commander Vaughn) against the Executor (with Lord Vader on the bridge).
 obi
07-20-2001, 1:24 AM
#82
yea, i like the I's myself, theyr are the only ones who look federation in origin, the III's look like romulan vessels.

the game is awesome, the last level took me forever to do.

THAT DANG CAPTAIN BRENNAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 MadPoster
07-20-2001, 9:20 PM
#83
TIE fighters take out a ST ship? Not even close. TIEs use lasers. ST sheilding has advanced to the point lasers won't do jack to them. And the ST phaser targeting system would nail a TIE cold. A phaser packs enough power to vaporize a TIE and most of its' wingmates, and still rock the ship they launched from. The standard ST torpedo can flatten a city, where SW torps take hordes to do the same.

FTL speed is the only advantage (other than sheer size of spacecraft) that SW has over ST.

So no, SW can't beat ST in a fight. But it is a moot point anyway, considering the two universes willl never officailly meet.
 BeastMaster
07-20-2001, 10:24 PM
#84
Agreed. I don't really like crossover fanfic. I prefer "re-interpretation" fanfic.

Not crossing over Star Wars and Star Trek, but putting the Star Trek ships & characters into the Star Wars universe (or vice-versa) and finding a way to do it without violating the "laws" of that universe.

One of these days I'm going to get around to doing my Buffy/Star Wars and Buffy/Star Trek fanfics.

This is Captain Buffy Summers of the Federation Starship Slayer to Admiral Rupert Giles, Priority One.

:cool:

[ July 20, 2001: Message edited by: BeastMaster ]
 Darth Prime
07-21-2001, 12:22 AM
#85
Madposter, what I was getting at is, TIE's are too small for the phasers to lock on to. And about the photon torpedoes, they can take out TIE's, but they only have a limited number. Another thing is that if their a huge number of TIE's and one group hit the ship with lasers over and over, that could cause damage.
 MadPoster
07-21-2001, 5:14 PM
#86
WRONG AGAIN. TIEs are an all too easy target for ST ships. The phasers can lock on to a human sized target if they need to. They wouldn't bother to use torpedoes on them, that would be a waste. And TIE laser cannons do NOTHING to the ST sheilds.
 pandemonium
07-21-2001, 7:11 PM
#87
MadPoster... your not actually being serious are you? ;) :p :eek:

Oh well, first time for everything I guess

[ July 21, 2001: Message edited by: Darth_Rommel ]
 obi
07-21-2001, 8:11 PM
#88
lol.........

for once i actually AGREE with madposter.
TIEs couldnt do anything to a Trek ship, or any rebel craft, for that matter.

if luke thinks he can whip the Enterprise in an x-wing using the force, he's dead wrong.

In a battle, Trek would make Wars look like a horde of jedi masters facing 2 or 3 banthas.
 pandemonium
07-21-2001, 8:32 PM
#89
*Gasps* obiwan13 *shakes head in dismay* I never thought you were a TRAITOR- how could you say that? :eek: :eek: :( :(
 Boba Rhett
07-21-2001, 11:13 PM
#90
I say it's about time we break out the crosses. hehehee...
 MadPoster
07-21-2001, 11:52 PM
#91
I just think that the ST vs SW debate is stupid. It is like comparing apples to thick, juicy, meaty, tasty hamburgers, smothered in mustard, with bacon, and cheese, and tomatoes, and... Damn. I'm hungery. Who's gonna go get some burgers? I'll buy.
 Darth Prime
07-22-2001, 1:57 AM
#92
MadPoster, I agree with you on that. This is getting stupid. It's starting to remind me of that dispute I got into with someone over abortion. It got to the point that if we both kept up we would've been temporaily banned.
 JediMasterHorn
07-22-2001, 7:28 AM
#93
My 2 cents:
TIEs could swarm a starship, because the lasers would have to lock on to each individual ship.

How do you know blasters fire "lasers"? Where has that been said? They use tibanna gas to produce the blaster shot, and for all we know a blaster could be composed of something similer to phaser fire. So that point is moot, unless you can prove otherwise, which you can't. As a matter of fact, we cant prove any of this, but dah-well.... :)

Besides, all you would have to do is get a group of Jedi and or sith together and have them use the Force to slag the shield genorators. Or they could take control of the minds of the command crew to lower the shields...or self destruct the ship and lock out all the controls...or transport JarJar aboards so he can annoy them to death or get them to commit suicide.... :D
 obi
07-22-2001, 11:42 AM
#94
Originally posted by Darth_Rommel:
<STRONG>*Gasps* obiwan13 *shakes head in dismay* I never thought you were a TRAITOR- how could you say that? :eek: :eek: :( :(</STRONG>

i'm not a traitor, I have more star wars stuff than a jawa has droids.

It's just i was surfin the net and saw where Trek and Wars met in a war, and trek came out on top, and left SW like the klingon Empire.

I thought that was quite disturbing, so i looked at several other fanfics, from ST AND SW fans, who both determined ST would be on top, so i decided to 'except the ineadable' and decide trek would win in a war.

but as i said, i have a lot SW merchindise, and the only thing i have of trek is a 2 video games. BTW, the only trek i like is TNG, and enterprise is gonna rule!
 darth terrat
07-22-2001, 12:04 PM
#95
:D What about man to man?saber V.S.
Phaser eh!! :D
 oninosensi
07-22-2001, 12:47 PM
#96
i disagree with this:
Besides, all you would have to do is get a group of Jedi and or sith together and have them use the Force to slag the shield genorators. Or they could take control of the minds of the command crew to lower the shields...or self destruct the ship and lock out all the controls


ST has it share of powerful telepaths and psychics. Whole races of 'em, so force users wouldn't be a huge advantage.

...or transport JarJar aboards so he can annoy them to death or get them to commit suicide....

Now that there is no defense against.
 ESE_Sithlord
07-22-2001, 2:40 PM
#97
SW would beat ST any day of the week. For one SW Has better/Stronger characters . Two they all have a background history that wipes the floor with any character from ST.


Luke Skywalker vs. Captian Kirk
Weapon: Lightsaber/Force vs. Vaser up to settings

Han Solo vs. Spock
Weapon: Blaster vs. Vaser

Darth Vader vs. Worf
Weapon: Lightsaber/Force vs. Sword Staff

Ya pick who wins Iam not sure about Spock and Solo though but I know the Jedi and Sith and even the Dark Jedi would kill the ST Characters.
 JediMasterHorn
07-22-2001, 4:58 PM
#98
Sure, Trek has telepaths, but not many serve on starships, and even then, do you really think they are more powerfull than Jedi?

Forget Jedi, get a few Dark Jedi/Sith together and they can take out a whole starship just using the force and cutting off blood flow to the brain in the crew. 1 Sec and its all over. :-D
Lets see them fancy schmancy shields stop that. hehe.
 pandemonium
07-22-2001, 6:09 PM
#99
I guess your not a traitor... just misguided!
;) :p ;) :p


oh yeah... thanks again for the great sig pic
obiwan13! :D :D :D

[ July 22, 2001: Message edited by: Darth_Rommel ]
 obi
07-22-2001, 8:08 PM
#100
traitor? nah. misguided? maybe. great sig? HECK YEA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

BTW, i used to hunt down sigs for people that wanted me too, back in the day. ;)
Page: 2 of 3