Note: LucasForums Archive Project
The content here was reconstructed by scraping the Wayback Machine in an effort to restore some of what was lost when LF went down. The LucasForums Archive Project claims no ownership over the content or assets that were archived on archive.org.

This project is meant for research purposes only.

TrueForm in Jedi II

Page: 1 of 1
 Xzalibur
06-07-2001, 7:51 PM
#1
ATI's new TrueForm technology can be implemented into any PC game and increase the polygons by a a factor of 10 without a drop in performance. And the chip will realease this summer. What's the point of getting a GeForce3 when all my old games like X-wing Alliance & even JK will have 10X more detail... there's NO WAY I'm getting a card from nVidia if it doesn't have a similar feature...

Take a look...
...and consider what this feature will do to Jedi II + all your present and future 3D games:
http://www.theinquirer.net/glave.jpg)
http://www.theinquirer.net/delfini.jpg)
ATI's Truform revealed (http://www.theinquirer.net/ati300501.htm)
ATI Trueform technology (http://www.anandtech.com/showdoc.html?i=1476)

[ June 07, 2001: Message edited by: Xzalibur ]
 NeJJa
06-07-2001, 7:54 PM
#2
sweet. cool. a gimmick. dont make me delve into why the GeForce 3 will stomp all over this card without even blinking.
 SithSeeD
06-07-2001, 7:55 PM
#3
hmmmm... I'll have to try and get one of those from my cousin. She works for ATI... maybe I could get a deal or get one free.

SithSeeD :mad:
 Jolts
06-07-2001, 8:00 PM
#4
Sounds cool, but is I would think adding all those extra polys would screw up the textures on the models making them funky looking. But maybe not, I want to see some textured examples
 Xzalibur
06-07-2001, 8:08 PM
#5
sweet. cool. a gimmick. dont make me delve into why the GeForce 3 will stomp all over this card without even blinking.We'll just have to wait and see then...

But in my opinion the GeForce3 is too expensive & older games will still look like they did on older cards...

Jolts >> I've seen that dolphine picture with textures aswell... I'll see if I can find that picture. The tuexture and lighting looked much better with TruForm although the original texture was pretty poor to begin with...
 Jolts
06-07-2001, 8:12 PM
#6
Xzalibur try and find a human face that is textured, the dolphin seems like it would have a pretty simple texture on it that wouldn't show that much is it was warped
 Sherack Nhar
06-07-2001, 8:24 PM
#7
In the Gamespot article, it is said that if the technology is ever implemented for older games on the drivers, it's going to need a little registry hack.

Trueform is outstanding technology, but ATi is just no match for NVIDIA's hype machine. :mad:

As far as being implemented in JK2, don't keep your hopes up. Don't forget that they only have a year to finish it. :(
 Xzalibur
06-07-2001, 8:37 PM
#8
Well I found the dolphine picture. As I said it's crappy and we all know that 10X more detail on a crappy object is still going to look bad:
Dolphine picture (http://www.amdzone.com/articleimages/truform/web3.jpg)

Example of the increased amount of triangels in a dolphine picture (http://www.amdzone.com/articleimages/truform/web4.jpg) Xzalibur try and find a human face that is textured, the dolphin seems like it would have a pretty simple texture on it that wouldn't show that much is it was warped
TruForm doesn't acctually change the textures - it just increases the amount of triangels in 3D models so the textures will look just fine. There isn't any pictures of human faces with TrueForm on the Net to my knowledge... but it will probably surface soon...

There's also an interview with ATI that might interest you: ATI's TRUFORM with David Nalasco (http://www.h2h.ca/truform.shtml)

Sherack Nhar >> The feature can be implemented in drivers for all games and/or in adding one simple line of code to the game...

[ June 07, 2001: Message edited by: Xzalibur ]
 Jolts
06-07-2001, 8:47 PM
#9
I'll get a Gforce3 first and wait and see what happens with this bad boy
 Rancor
06-07-2001, 11:51 PM
#10
Gimmick. Sorry, but just imagine what adding smoothing would do to something that was supposed to have defined hard edges. On the other hand, maybe there is something that they haven't said yet about how it might be smart and only smooth certain things, but that just sounds like a crapshoot. I'm not saying NVidia is da bomb either, but I think the GeForce3 is in some ways a big step in the right direction. As for ATI, at least they are better than the old 3Dfx voodoo3 garbage.

In the end though, everyone freaks about graphics and very few people seem to really care about quality gameplay. Fortunately though, I think many people on this message board may be the exception to that rule. So if we start pressing the devs to get stuff in the game, let's press them to make stellar gameplay ( hint, hint ).

[ June 07, 2001: Message edited by: Rancor ]
 bsbuckeye21
06-08-2001, 1:08 AM
#11
I don't like the way ATi puts extra lighting on the higher-poly models. Tru-From doesn't do anything for that. False advertising if you ask me.
 Letalis
06-08-2001, 2:17 AM
#12
Yay for gameplay!
 Archie
06-08-2001, 7:26 AM
#13
Firstly, GeForce3 will make old games look better, it has basically free FSAA, and will run them in higher resolutions, at higher bitdepths...

As for TrueForm, what use is it when you have high poly source art :D?
 Aragorn
06-08-2001, 12:39 PM
#14
I think we should wait for these new graphics cards to prove themselves before we rush into a store and blindly buy one...
 Thrawn
06-08-2001, 10:48 PM
#15
1.I'm cheap
2.I'm saving up for a new CPU, motherboard, and memory
3.I'm happy with my Geforce DDR with the latest set of drivers. Gameplay is what matters most. As long as I have a smooth frame rate, I'm fine.
 Xzalibur
06-09-2001, 4:20 PM
#16
Originally posted by Jolts: Xzalibur try and find a human face that is texturedI've found two small pictures from a demo running on the current Radeon board. TrueForm is implemented in software so it will be much faster on the real card (probably 10 times) and it'll most likely look even better:
http://mwill.hypermart.net/images/truform.jpg)
http://mwill.hypermart.net/images/truquake.jpg)
 CaptainRAVE
06-09-2001, 4:28 PM
#17
ATI used to be really good.....they suck these days!
 magnus
06-09-2001, 5:32 PM
#18
according to this technology I don't think ATI suck, I think they rule!

Think of what this could do for games... the possibilities are endless...

jummy :)
 Rancor
06-09-2001, 5:52 PM
#19
I don't like the way ATi puts extra lighting on the higher-poly models. Tru-From doesn't do anything for that. False advertising if you ask me.

Nah, it's not adding any extra lighting. Since the one model is so low poly, it doesn't really pick up the hi-lights properly. As soon as you add ten times as many verticies, if you are doing vertex based lighted ( which most games would use for in-game models )...the results just naturally look more realistic/pronounced.
 CaptainRAVE
06-09-2001, 6:58 PM
#20
Their nowhere near as good as Geforce though, when i got my Geforce i snapped my ATI Card in half :)
Page: 1 of 1