This only happens in Rise Of The Empire. I have the PS2 version.
My problem is on the Knightfall Level in Rise Of The Empire, where once I play Anakin, I can attack people, but he doesn't kill anyone. The only way he can kill someone is by throwing his Lightsaber or by Choking an enemy.
Is this a glitch? I'll say it again, it only happens in Rise Of The Empire.
I've played 'rise of the empire' a lot of times and I didn't had this 'glitch'
I can easily kill enemy's with Anakin
You should try hitting harder :D