I can't seem to find him anywhere.
Oh, guess where you have to go to find him. (If I think you know where you are, but you have to be more speciifc next time.)
Are you sure he's not standing right in front of you? Maybe the milkman is nearby, but he thinks he's someone else because of some...mental blockages?
No seriously, I just left the island where the guard won't let me in.......where do I go now? I've gone everywhere and nothing has changed except it's night. I really don't want a riddle, seriously WHAT DO I DO NOW?
It's not that hard. Go back to the island and use your bacon.
take the mental door sasha gave you and use it on the guard.