Originally posted by Valkian
Due to the lack of explanation I gave here goes a more serious one: I certainly look at games in an objective way, and not only games also movies, music, comics, book
and any other art form.
I think no one here is in the position to point and say: "This is wrong!". You could say: "I don't like this" we all have different tastes. You could only say that something is wrong ONLY if you CAN MAKE IT better.
A team of 30 people spent about three years of their lives making this game, and you are NO ONE to point with your meaningless finger and say: "This is wrong!" because I BET my own life that you CAN'T even make something half that creative. NOT even if you spend your whole life trying.
I agree, there is no perfect game. BUT there is a perfect game for me, that may not be perfect for you, and that's how the world spins.
So go ahead, play the game, and then say:"I love it" or "I like it" or "I don't like it" or "I hate it" and then go on with your life. But don't you DARE to JUDGE, no one is in position to JUDGE anything here, nor you, me or Oh-so-mighty-Mr.Schafer. No one.
I could also bet my life that at least someone is going to complain about my site (
http://dig.mixnmojo.com) 1st link and I'm in shame) when I release it (soon, I promise) but I'm sure that if I say to that person: "Fine, you are in charge of this site now BUT I'm taking away all I've done so far, so go ahead and start from the scratch" he/she would piss on his/her pants. Everyone loves talking about anything. But the ones that actually DO something (and do it well) are a minority.
Ok, now you can go on with your pathetic lives. Yeah, I'm pissed off. So what?....I need a drink...
P.S: You can call me Sam, but NEVER EVER call me just Valkian. For you it's: "Oh fearless light among shadows, lift me up powerful Valkian" It's not that hard.
Um, who exactly are you talking to here? Because if that was a general message to everyone, it was kinda harsh. If it was a specfic message to VampireNaomi (intended for everyone to see, obviously) then it was still a little harsh, especially when you said that you'd bet your own life she couldn't come up with anything half as imginative ever. How exactly do you know that, do you know VampireNaomi as a person, do you know anyone here well enough to make that assumption? For all you know, there could be little Tim Scafer's here waiting for that oppertunity to let their imagination run wild and create something that may one day rival the work of Schafer, anythings possible.
Also, if you can give a valid reason as to why something has something wrong with it, the creator can generally use that in improving that thing or in the next thing they do, so in effect, that criticism has made a change. There's no problem in saying it's wrong.
Also saying somethings wrong doesn't depend on the fact that you should be able to do better. A mathematician could look at an extremely complex equation that no one could solve and put down an answer to it. If the answer is wrong another mathematician could look at it and say so without saying that he could solve it. I could quite easily say that psychonauts was bad because after twenty minutes it got boring (I'm talking hypothetical here, this probably won't happen). This doesn't mean that I could create a similar game that kept me enthralled for hours on end, the only way I'd suggest that is if I said something like "I could do better than that!" at which point I would expect someone to come along and tell me to do just that, which would put me in my place.